Privacy

Surveillance is prevalent in all of our lives, to different degrees, and each of us deserves privacy. It is a human right that has been increasingly complicated with the collection and control of our digital data. Such work seeks to advance democratic, ethical, and just uses of technology in schools and society. One of our initiatives at Civics of Technology, led by board member Dr. Morgan Banville, seeks to empower both students and educators to critically inquire into the effects of technologies on their individual and collective lives. On this page, you will find curriculum, resources, and events to use in your context.

In addition, every January we host a Privacy Event. For more information, visit our Privacy Week Pages, linked below. The series is in response to the yearly Data Privacy Week initiatives created by the National Cybersecurity Alliance.

Decorative Image

A note from Morgan: What follows is a starting place for educators seeking to incorporate texts about privacy and surveillance into their classroom space. The reading list and additional resources are broken into categories, with abstracts pasted below the citation from the article and/or publisher website, both for ease of access and to assist with choosing relevant texts for educators’ classroom context. Again, these are not my own words (except for my own articles!). This list is not exhaustive but rather extends from some of my own comprehensive exam reading for my Ph.D. in Rhetoric, Writing, and Professional Communication. Readers will therefore notice that while surveillance studies as a field are highly interdisciplinary, many texts are rooted in rhetoric, technical communication, and writing studies broadly speaking. In addition, many of the texts are U.S. centric to appeal and connect with the CoT audience; however, it is important to note that both privacy and surveillance are global issues. We will be working on creating a comprehensive global reading list as well. 

When we refer to privacy, we refer to the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) who defines privacy as “freedom from intrusion into the private life or affairs of an individual when that intrusion results from undue or illegal gathering and use of data about that individual” (Garfinkel, S., Near, J., Dajani A. N., Singer, P., & Guttman, B., 2023). When we refer to surveillance, we mean “the collection of both visible and invisible data/information derived from those being observed, suggesting an application of power over the observed audience, who are often not informed of such collection” (Banville, 2023, p. 32). 

This work seeks to contribute to Civics of Technology's mission, aiming to empower both students and educators to critically inquire into the effects of technologies on their individual and collective lives. Surveillance is prevalent in all of our lives, to different degrees, and privacy is a right that each of us values. Such work seeks to advance democratic, ethical, and just uses of technology in schools and society. These are issues Civics of Technology readers and members are well apt to address and challenge in their lives and pedagogical practice.  

“The power that privacy grants us collectively as citizens is necessary for democracy–for us to vote according to our beliefs and without undue pressure, for us to protest anonymously without fear of repercussions, to have freedom to associate, speak our minds, read what we are curious about.” - Carissa Véliz, author of Privacy is Power: Why and How You Should Take Back Control of Your Data 

If you have any questions or would like to contribute texts, resources, assignments, or would like to participate in Privacy Week, please email Dr. Morgan Banville at morgancbanville@gmail.com.

Reading List

  • Defining Privacy

    Bennett, C. J. (2011). In defense of privacy: The concept and the regime. Surveillance & Society, 8(4), 485-496. https://doi.org/10.24908/ss.v8i4.4184 

    It has recently become fashionable within the surveillance studies community to subject the concept and regime of “privacy protection” to some very rigorous criticism.   “Privacy” and all that it entails is argued to be too narrow, too based on liberal assumptions of subjectivity, too implicated in rights-based theory and discourse, insufficiently sensitive to the social sorting and discriminatory aspects of surveillance, and overly embroiled in spatial metaphors about “invasion” and “intrusion.”  As a concept, and as a way to frame the various social and political challenges encountered within “surveillance societies,” it is inadequate.   These critiques are important, and to some extent, have set scholarly inquiry on a new, exciting and broader, trajectory than that offered by privacy scholars. On closer examination, however, these critiques are often based on some faulty assumptions about the contemporary framing of the privacy issue, and about the governance of the issue.  Privacy, as a concept, regime, a set of policy instruments, and as a way to frame civil society activism, shows an extraordinary resilience. Surveillance scholars must learn to live with it. 

    Hong, S. (2017). Criticising surveillance and surveillance critique: Why privacy and humanism are necessary but insufficient. Surveillance & Society 15(2), 187–202. https://doi.org/10.24908/ss.v15i2.5441 

    The current debate on surveillance, both academic and public, is constantly tempted towards a ‘negative’ criticism of present surveillance systems. In contrast, a ‘positive’ critique would be one which seeks to present alternative ways of thinking, evaluating, and even undertaking surveillance. Surveillance discourse today propagates a host of normative claims about what is admissible as ‘true’, ‘probable’, ‘efficient’ – based upon which it cannot fail to justify itself. A positive critique questions and subverts this epistemological foundation. It believes that surveillance must be held accountable by terms other than those of its own making. The objective is an open debate not only about ‘surveillance or not’, but the possibility of ‘another surveillance’. To demonstrate the necessity of this shift, I first examine two existing frames of criticism. Privacy  and humanism (appeal to human rights, freedoms and decency) are necessary but insufficient tools for positive critique. They implicitly accept surveillance’s bargain of trade-offs: the benefit of security ‘measured’ against the cost of rights. To demonstrate paths towards positive critique, I analyse risk and security: two ‘load-bearing’ concepts that ground existing rationalisations of surveillance – and thus are ‘openings’ for reforming those evaluative paradigms and rigged bargains on offer today. 

    Nissenbaum, H. F. (1998). Protecting privacy in an information age: The problem of privacy in public. Law and Philosophy. https://ssrn.com/abstract=139144. 

    Philosophical and legal theories of privacy have long recognized the relationship between privacy and information about persons. They have, however, focused on personal, intimate, and sensitive information, assuming that with public information, and information drawn from public spheres, either privacy norms do not apply, or applying privacy norms is so burdensome as to be morally and legally unjustifiable. Against this preponderant view, I argue that information and communications technology, by facilitating surveillance, by vastly enhancing the collection, storage, and analysis of information, by enabling profiling, data mining and aggregation, has significantly altered the meaning of public information. As a result, a satisfactory legal and philosophical understanding of a right to privacy, capable of protecting the important values at stake in protecting privacy, must incorporate, in addition to traditional aspects of privacy, a degree of protection for privacy in public. 

    Pollak, C. (2021). Legitimation and textual evidence: how the Snowden leaks reshaped the ACLU’s online writing about NSA surveillance. Written Communication, 38(3), 380-416. https://doi.org/10.1177/07410883211007870 

    Scholars in discourse studies have defined legitimation as the justification (and critique) of powerful institutions and their practices. In moments of crisis, legitimation tactics often shift. This article considers how such shifts are incited by unauthorized information leaks. Leaks, I argue, constitute freshly available texts that reveal privileged institutional information presented in a specialized rhetorical style. To explore how leaks are harnessed by institutional critics, I examine the 2013 Snowden/National Security Agency (NSA) crisis. Combining corpus analysis with discourse analysis, I explore how Snowden’s NSA leaks affected the online writing of the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU). I also consider overlaps between the rhetorical patterns in the leaked NSA documents and those in the ACLU’s post-leaks writing. Findings from my analysis of legitimation and style categories suggest that, prior to the leaks, ACLU writers primarily used a character- and narrative-based style to delegitimize the NSA’s policies as illegal and secretive, and to push for their reform. After the leaks, though, the ACLU mainly used an informationally dense style rife with academic terms and vocabularies of strategic action, portraying NSA surveillance as massive and complex. As the documents moved from the NSA’s secret, technical discourses to public, critical discourses, the latter came to resemble the former rhetorically. These findings raise crucial questions about how critics can make use of leaks without necessarily relegitimizing institutional power. 

    Skinner-Thompson, S. (2020). Privacy at the margins. Cambridge University Press. 

    Limited legal protections for privacy leave minority communities vulnerable to concrete injuries and violence when their information is exposed. In Privacy at the Margins, Scott Skinner-Thompson highlights why privacy is of acute importance for marginalized groups. He explains how privacy can serve as a form of expressive resistance to government and corporate surveillance regimes - furthering equality goals - and demonstrates why efforts undertaken by vulnerable groups (queer folks, women, and racial and religious minorities) to protect their privacy should be entitled to constitutional protection under the First Amendment and related equality provisions. By examining the ways even limited privacy can enrich and enhance our lives at the margins in material ways, this work shows how privacy can be transformed from a liberal affectation to a legal tool of liberation from oppression. 

    Stalder, F. (2002). Privacy is not the antidote to surveillance. Surveillance & Society, 1(1), 120–124. https://doi.org/10.24908/ss.v1i1.3397 

    The standard reaction to the problem of surveillance is to demand the protection of privacy. This article, however, argues that the conventional notion of privacy, based, as it is, on the separation of the individual from their environment, is no longer useful in the context of ubiquitous electronic communication. Rather than defending ever shrinking areas of privacy, we should refocus our efforts and demand accountability from those design and employ the new communication systems. 

    Véliz, C. (2021). Privacy is power: How and why you should take back control of your data. Brooklyn, NY. Melville House Publishing. 

    Selected by the Economist as one of the best books of 2020. Privacy Is Power argues that people should protect their personal data because privacy is a kind of power. If we give too much of our data to corporations, the wealthy will rule. If we give too much personal data to governments, we risk sliding into authoritarianism. For democracy to be strong, the bulk of power needs to be with the citizenry, and whoever has the data will have the power. Privacy, I argue, is not a personal preference; it is a political concern. I also argue that personal data is a toxic asset, and should be regulated as if it were a toxic substance, similar to asbestos. I call for a complete ban to the trade in personal data. The book is at once philosophical and political, and extremely practical and accessible. It discusses liberal democracy, equality, justice, and autonomy. It includes a chapter for policymakers, and one that addresses what ordinary citizens can do to protect privacy. Finally, the book covers the tension between privacy and public health in the context of COVID19. 

  • Methods and Methodologies

    Banville, M. C., & Johnson, G. P. (Eds.). (2024). Talking back through rhetorical surveillance studies: Intersectional feminist and queer approaches [Cluster Conversation]. Peitho, 27(1), 71–225. https://doi.org/10.37514/PEI-J.2024.27.1.05 

    While surveillance practices have long histories that pre-date the digital age, recent transnational events have brought into sharper focus the prevalence of surveillance and its targets, especially multiply marginalized communities who are women, LGBTQIA+, disabled, Black, Indigenous, and people of color. This rhetorical moment requires our attention and collective action. That is, our academic scholarship and public discourse cannot ignore or downplay the oppressive lunge toward ever-increasing surveillance. With this cluster conversation, our goal is to invite and enact a talking back to surveillance infrastructures of power in a way that is a “gesture of defiance that heals, that makes new life and new growth possible” (hooks 9; Browne 62). “Talking back,” as we use it here, comes from the critical work of Black feminists. We set the stage for talking back to surveillance practices, technologies, and cultures using a repertoire of feminist and queer rhetorics. Our goal is to argue for the sustained and sustainable study of surveillance in rhetorical studies but, more specifically, insist on forwarding intersectional feminist and queer frameworks in that study. In this introduction to the cluster conversation, the editors briefly review major moves and important concepts in the interdisciplinary field of Surveillance Studies. This cluster conversation features nine manuscripts, exploring the following themes: State and Government Surveillance, Surveillance of Women’s Bodies and Surveillance Technologies, Surveillance in Schools, and Tactics. Through this cluster, we hope to establish not only the need for rhetorical surveillance studies grounded in intersectional feminist and queer practices but also uplift the voices of emerging scholars and graduate students already talking back. 

    Beauchamp, T. (2019). Going stealth: Transgender politics and U.S. surveillance practices. Durham, NC: Duke University Press. 

    Beauchamp demonstrates how the enforcement of gender conformity is linked to state surveillance practices that identify threats based on racial, gender, national, and ableist categories of difference. Positioning surveillance as central to our understanding of transgender politics, Beauchamp examines a range of issues, from bathroom bills and TSA screening practices to Chelsea Manning's trial, to show how security practices extend into the everyday aspects of our gendered lives. He brings the fields of disability, science and technology, and surveillance studies into conversation with transgender studies to show how the scrutinizing of gender nonconformity is motivated less by explicit transgender identities than by the perceived threat that gender nonconformity poses to the U.S. racial and security state. Beauchamp uses instances of gender surveillance to demonstrate how disciplinary power attempts to produce conformist citizens and regulate difference through discourses of security. At the same time, he contends that greater visibility and recognition for gender nonconformity, while sometimes beneficial, might actually enable the surveillance state to more effectively track, measure, and control trans bodies and identities. 

    Beck, E., Goin, M. E., Ho, A., Parks, A., & Rowe, S. (2021). Critical digital literacy as method for teaching tactics of response to online surveillance and privacy erosion. Computers and Composition, 61, 102654. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compcom.2021.102654 

    Many educators teach students digital literacies in undergraduate writing courses. One type of literacy, critical digital literacy, offers student learning opportunities by applying Hutchinson and Novotny's critical digital literacy as method. In this article, through the application of critical digital literacy, the authors present aspects of a course design and extracurricular projects on how to identify, understand, and respond to online surveillance and privacy erosion. They present four tactics of response educators and students can use in courses as part of an overall course, major assignment or activities. Based on the pedagogical findings, the authors suggest educators adopt critical digital literacy as a framework. 

    Dubrofsky, R. E. & Magnet, S. A. (2015). Feminist surveillance studies. Durham, NC: Duke University Press. 

    Questions of gender, race, class, and sexuality have largely been left unexamined in surveillance studies. The contributors to this field-defining collection take up these questions, and in so doing provide new directions for analyzing surveillance. They use feminist theory to expose the ways in which surveillance practices and technologies are tied to systemic forms of discrimination that serve to normalize whiteness, able-bodiedness, capitalism, and heterosexuality. The essays discuss the implications of, among others, patriarchal surveillance in colonial North America, surveillance aimed at curbing the trafficking of women and sex work, women presented as having agency in the creation of the images that display their bodies via social media, full-body airport scanners, and mainstream news media discussion of honor killings in Canada and the concomitant surveillance of Muslim bodies. Rather than rehashing arguments as to whether or not surveillance keeps the state safe, the contributors investigate what constitutes surveillance, who is scrutinized, why, and at what cost. The work fills a gap in feminist scholarship and shows that gender, race, class, and sexuality should be central to any study of surveillance. 

  • Pedagogy

    Beck, E., & Hutchinson Campos, L. (2021). Introduction. Privacy matters: Conversations about surveillance within and beyond the classroom. Louisville, CO. UP of Colorado. 

    Privacy Matters examines how communications and writing educators, administrators, technological resource coordinators, and scholars can address the ways surveillance and privacy affect student and faculty composing, configure identity formation, and subvert the surveillance state. This collection offers practical analyses of surveillance and privacy as they occur within classrooms and communities. Organized by themes—surveillance and classrooms, surveillance and bodies, surveillance and culture—Privacy Matters provides writing, rhetoric, and communication scholars and teachers with specific approaches, methods, inquiries, and examinations into the impact tracking and monitoring has upon people’s habits, bodies, and lived experiences. 

     Fernandes, M., & McIntyre, M. (2025). Drafting defensively, documenting authorship: An analysis of Draftback and Grammarly Authorship. Computers and Composition, 76, 102926. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compcom.2025.102926 

    In this piece, we offer critical interface analyses of two process surveillance interfaces, a term we use to describe personal writing tools that track students’ writing process via edits, revisions, and inserted text. Specifically, we examine: Draftback, a Google extension that predates ChatGPT-3, and Grammarly Authorship, a new beta feature for Grammarly users. Situated in scholarly conversations in digital cultural rhetorics, writing studies, surveillance studies, and user experience design, we analyze how these process surveillance interfaces reinscribe normative values for writing as product (rather than process) and facilitate feelings of suspicion, anxiety, and defensiveness for users. This analysis has implications both for instructors seeking to teach with tools like Draftback and Authorship to verify “responsible” GenAI use and instructors seeking to implement punitive anti-AI policies. Though Draftback and Grammarly Authorship are different kinds of process surveillance interfaces, they pose similar threats to writing process instruction when used for academic integrity purposes by either students or instructors. Namely, we find three issues associated with three process surveillance interfaces; namely, these tools promote 1) product over process; 2) normative constructions of embodiment and time; and 3) adversarial student-instructor dynamics.  

    Licastro, A., & Miller, B. M. (Eds.). (2021). Composition and big data. University of Pittsburgh Press. 

    In a data-driven world, anything can be data. As the techniques and scale of data analysis advance, the need for a response from rhetoric and composition grows ever more pronounced. It is increasingly possible to examine thousands of documents and peer-review comments, labor-hours, and citation networks in composition courses and beyond. Composition and Big Data brings together a range of scholars, teachers, and administrators already working with big-data methods and datasets to kickstart a collective reckoning with the role that algorithmic and computational approaches can, or should, play in research and teaching in the field. Their work takes place in various contexts, including programmatic assessment, first-year pedagogy, stylistics, and learning transfer across the curriculum. From ethical reflections to database design, from corpus linguistics to quantitative autoethnography, these chapters implement and interpret the drive toward data in diverse ways. 

    Vie, S. (2013). A pedagogy of resistance toward plagiarism detection technologies. Computers and Composition, 30(1), 3-15. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compcom.2013.01.002 

    This article interrogates the use of plagiarism detection devices from a critical and rhetorical standpoint, using both plagiarism detection technologies as well as essay mills as sites for analysis and subversion. My goal is to argue for a pedagogy of resistance to plagiarism detection technologies. Both plagiarism detection sites and online paper mills play into the very issue we as rhetoricians and compositionists should be resisting; that is, by upholding the singular notion of authorship as something individualistic, commercialized, and commodified, these sites reinforce individual authorship to the detriment of more communal forms of writing that are prized in online environments such as social networking sites, blogs, wikis, and so on. If we are forced into the circular logic of avoiding plagiarism/catching plagiarists/punishing plagiarism and prizing singular authorship above all other forms, then we risk failing to find the ability to break free and move beyond to more challenging modes of writing that rely on community. The potential time-saving benefits of plagiarism detection services—that is, the ease of discovering potential plagiarism—may unfortunately lull us into compliance and cause us to forget that there are larger issues regarding copyright law and ownership of ideas still up for debate. 

    Young, S. J. (2023). Working through surveillance in technical communication. Albany, NY. SUNY Press. 

    What is surveillance, and why should we care? Why are those who use technology susceptible to being both agents and targets of contemporary surveillance practices? Working Through Surveillance and Technical Communication addresses these questions, discussing what it means to engage in surveillance, examining why this participation may be problematic, and offering entry points into assessing one's ethical and socially just involvement with surveillance. Further, the book suggests ways to resist both individually and collectively, and it offers pedagogical entry points for those looking to talk about surveillance with others. Led by the central questions, "How are technical communicators also surveillance workers?" and "Why does this matter for technical communication and surveillance scholarship?" the text uses the example of Edward Snowden to illustrate how technical communicators and surveillance workers exist on an often-overlapping range. Sarah Young highlights the potentially discriminatory nature of surveillance and argues that recognizing and evaluating surveillance in is increasingly important in a data-driven world. 

  • Biometrics and Wearable Devices

    Al-Khateeb, M. T. (2020). Toward a rhetorical account of refugee encounters: Biometric screening technologies and failed promises of mobility. Rhetoric Society Quarterly, 51(1), 15-26. https://doi.org/10.1080/02773945.2020.1841276  

    This essay brings together scholarship in biometrics and disability studies with conversations in transnational rhetorical studies to build a theoretical framework that examines the (re)emergence and (re)circulation of biometric screening technologies and attends to the role of technologies in theorizing an ethics of encounter. I argue specifically that tracing biometrics—discursive, material, and technological practices—reveals how such discourses and their promises materialize on bodies of refugees and shape their encounters as “others and other-others.” Using this framework, I analyze rhetorically cultural artifacts that circulated following the 2015 and 2016 terrorist attacks in Europe and the United States to demonstrate how biometric screening discourses of progress have participated in immobilizing refugees physically and exacerbating conditions of biopolitical control and debilitation.  

    Banville, M. C. (2020). Resisting surveillance: Responding to wearable device privacy policies. SIGDOC ‘20: Proceedings of the 38th ACM International Conference on Design of Communication (pp. 1–8). https://doi.org/10.1145/3380851.3416764 

    This pilot study considers risk in association with wearable devices by placing body-monitoring in conversation with privacy policies (i.e. who is controlling your data, by what means, and to what end). This article focuses on the increasingly commonplace embodied technology that is both pervasive and invasive to individuals’ privacy as determined through the device users’ interpretation of corporate privacy policies. The primary focus is on the underexplored intersection of undergraduate students, wearable technology, and privacy, which ultimately advocates for transparency in corporate privacy policies. In this pilot study, it was found that users who read through the privacy policies of Fitbit and Google are more likely to change their passwords and emails, pay more attention to legal jargon, and may be less likely to link all of their applications through Google. 

    Banville, M. (2024). Exploring a case of surveillance: Pedagogical and programmatic influence(s) of biometric technology. Programmatic Perspectives, 15(1). Retrieved from https://programmaticperspectives.cptsc.org/index.php/jpp/article/view/64 

    This article provides insights into the programmatic and pedagogical impacts of a research study and its exigency in technical communication classes/programs. Grounded in surveillance studies and technical communication, this study defines biometric identification technologies as personal identifiers of the body, focusing specifically on how neonatal nurses use and perceive such technologies within the context of the United States healthcare system. Drawing from a corpus of communication materials from biometric companies, questionnaires, and ten interviews with neonatal nurses, this study explores how major themes and takeaways from the data collection can be implemented in the technical communication classroom. Technical communication courses may benefit from exploration of surveillance technologies in healthcare (and other sites of surveillance). As healthcare (and many other industries) become increasingly reliant on digital technologies, it is imperative for faculty (and students) to explore the ways pervasive technologies impact our agency, privacy, communication practices, and personal/professional lives and careers. 

    Banville, M., & Harrison, K. (2025). Biometrics at the border: Reimagining opt out logic. In C. Morris (Ed.) Special Issue on Technical Communication In/Against Security Logics. The Journal of Technical Writing and Communication. https://doi.org/10.1177/00472816251384948 

    This article demonstrates how biometric technologies operate through security logics, and how technical communicators can resist the process of securitization through what we refer to as “opt-out logics.” We question security logics through a case example of public-facing documentation from the Transportation Security Administration on the use of biometric technologies for domestic travel at airports across the United States. Our analysis focuses on three security logics: improving efficiency, mitigating risk, and paternalistic concern for passenger experience. To consider how these logics structure encounters, both authors provide personal narratives of their experience with biometric technologies in airports. Finally, drawing from tactical technical communication, we offer opt-out logics as modes of resistance in three categories: documentation, pedagogy, and design. We argue tactics of resistance are ways technical communicators can engage in resisting the expectation to opt in to systems. 

  • Borders and Barriers

    Benjamin, R. (2019). Race after technology: Abolitionist tools for the new Jim code. Oxford, England: Polity. 

    From everyday apps to complex algorithms, Ruha Benjamin cuts through tech-industry hype to understand how emerging technologies can reinforce White supremacy and deepen social inequity. Benjamin argues that automation, far from being a sinister story of racist programmers scheming on the dark web, has the potential to hide, speed up, and deepen discrimination while appearing neutral and even benevolent when compared to the racism of a previous era. Presenting the concept of the “New Jim Code,” she shows how a range of discriminatory designs encode inequity by explicitly amplifying racial hierarchies; by ignoring but thereby replicating social divisions; or by aiming to fix racial bias but ultimately doing quite the opposite. Moreover, she makes a compelling case for race itself as a kind of technology, designed to stratify and sanctify social injustice in the architecture of everyday life. This illuminating guide provides conceptual tools for decoding tech promises with sociologically informed skepticism. In doing so, it challenges us to question not only the technologies we are sold but also the ones we ourselves manufacture. 

    Browne, S. (2015). Dark matters: On the surveillance of blackness. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.  

    Simone Browne locates the conditions of blackness as a key site through which surveillance is practiced, narrated, and resisted. She shows how contemporary surveillance technologies and practices are informed by the long history of racial formation and by the methods of policing black life under slavery, such as branding, runaway slave notices, and lantern laws. Placing surveillance studies into conversation with the archive of transatlantic slavery and its afterlife, Browne draws from black feminist theory, sociology, and cultural studies to analyze texts as diverse as the methods of surveilling blackness she discusses: from the design of the eighteenth-century slave ship Brooks, Jeremy Bentham's Panopticon, and The Book of Negroes, to contemporary art, literature, biometrics, and post-9/11 airport security practices. Surveillance, Browne asserts, is both a discursive and material practice that reifies boundaries, borders, and bodies around racial lines, so much so that the surveillance of blackness has long been, and continues to be, a social and political norm.  

    Fojas, C. (2021). Border optics: Surveillance cultures on the US-Mexico frontier. New York University Press. 

    When Donald Trump promised to “build a wall” on the U.S.-Mexico border, both supporters and opponents visualized a snaking barrier of concrete cleaving through nearly two thousand miles of arid desert. Though only 4 percent of the US population lives in proximity to the border, imagining what the wall would look like came easily to most Americans, in part because of how images of the border are reproduced and circulated for national audiences. Border Optics considers the US-Mexico border as one of the most visualized and imagined spaces in the US. As a place of continual crisis, permanent visibility, and territorial defense, the border is rendered as a layered visual space of policing—one that is seen from watchtowers, camera-mounted vehicles, helicopters, surveillance balloons, radar systems, unmanned aerial vehicles, and live streaming websites. It is also a space that is visualized across various forms and genres of media, from maps to geographical surveys, military strategic plans, illustrations, photographs, postcards, novels, film, and television, which combine fascination with the region with the visual codes of surveillance and survey. Border Optics elaborates on the expanded vision of the border as a consequence of the interface of militarism, technology, and media. Camilla Fojas describes how the perception of the viewing public is controlled through a booming security-industrial complex made up of entertainment media, local and federal police, prisons and detention centers, the aerospace industry, and all manner of security technology industries. The first study to examine visual codes of surveillance within an analysis of the history and culture of the border region, Border Optics is an innovative and groundbreaking examination of security cultures, race, gender, and colonialism. 

    Gaeta, A. (2024). A disability theory of anti-surveillance tactics. In M. C. Banville and G. P. Johnson (Eds)., Talking back through rhetorical surveillance studies: Intersectional feminist and queer approaches [Cluster Conversation]. Peitho, 27(1). https://doi.org/10.37514/PEI-J.2024.27.1.12 

    This article sketches how disabled people resist surveillance in the liberal democracies of the Global North. Since there is a dearth of scholarship on disability and surveillance, this article first overviews the surveillance state’s primary mechanisms of capture inflicted on disabled people. Building on insights from queer, trans, and feminist surveillance studies, I gesture toward the need for disability surveillance studies. Second, I outline tactics used by disabled people to resist surveillance as well as tactics of my creation inspired by activist practices and recent events in social organizing. Highlighting the radicality of these tactics validates disabled people as critical knowers and makers in the efforts of anti-surveillance. Lastly, I use crip theory to contend that examining how disabled people experience and fight surveillance is insufficient to account for the ways that the disability-ability binary—as a structural set of relations—shapes the discursive and material production and execution of surveillance. 

    Jordan, R. (2024). Studying surveillance through hybrid concealment practices: A queer analysis of digital sex work safety guides. In M. C. Banville & G. P. Johnson (Eds)., Talking back through rhetorical surveillance studies: Intersectional feminist and queer approaches [Cluster Conversation]. Peitho, 27(1). https://doi.org/10.37514/PEI-J.2024.27.1.14 

    This article explores surveillance by analyzing the hybridity and concealment in digital sex work safety guides from multiple countries. Sex workers are the “canaries in the digital coalmine” (Sly) as surveillance, including laws and censorship, are “tried out” on sex workers before more “mainstream” users. Through analysis, this paper bridges sex worker voices with “queer surveillance” scholarship (Kafer and Grinberg) to study how sex workers work within/against systems of surveillance by utilizing the “hybrid concealment” necessary for hypermarginalized users when participating in digital spaces. These tactics, then, “talk back” through surveillance by centering sex workers’ critical positions in their writing about combatting surveilling practices. We must continue analyzing, assessing, and addressing concealment/visibility: who gets to be visible and why and when; how do we weave concealment for imperative safety, privacy, and protection, especially when trying to enact harm reduction against criminalization and connected surveillance practices? 

    Kafer, G., & Grinberg, D. (2019). Queer surveillance, [Special Issue], Surveillance & Society, 17(5). Retrieved from: https://ojs.library.queensu.ca/index.php/surveillance-and-society/issue/view/804 

    This special issue explores the productive resonances and tensions between surveillance studies and queer studies. The issue also launches our new Dialogue section with a set of provocations for “decolonizing surveillance studies.” 

    Kotzeva, E. (2024). Face-Shaping Power of the Postfeminist Gaze, or Digital Rhetorical Lateral Surveillance in Armenia. In M. C. Banville & G. P. Johnson (Eds)., Talking back through rhetorical surveillance studies: Intersectional feminist and queer approaches [Cluster Conversation]. Peitho, 27(1). https://doi.org/10.37514/PEI-J.2024.27.1.09 

    This article draws on feminist surveillance theoretical work to discuss digital lateral surveillance that objectifies the female body on social media and normalizes conformity with popular beauty standards. It studies how female social media users allow the postfeminist gaze to control, condition, and modify their bodies and identities. The piece argues that digital lateral surveillance has rhetorical character because it is a product both of the synopticon where many observe the few, an interpellation of the institution of patriarchy in the digital age, and the gynaeopticon, a type of neoliberal female peer surveillance. The analysis focuses on the functioning of the postfeminist gaze in social media posts and user comments regarding the unconventional appearance of an Armenian model. The study further theorizes rhetorical practices of techno-feminist resistance which can help female social media users revise their relationship with technology to regain agency over the construction of their bodies, identities, and realities. 

    Monahan, T. (2022). Crisis vision: Race and the cultural production of surveillance. Durham, NC: Duke University Press. 

    Monahan explores how artists confront the racializing dimensions of contemporary surveillance. He focuses on artists ranging from Kai Wiedenhöfer, Paolo Cirio, and Hank Willis Thomas to Claudia Rankine and Dread Scott, who engage with what he calls crisis vision—the regimes of racializing surveillance that position black and brown bodies as targets for police and state violence. Many artists, Monahan contends, remain invested in frameworks that privilege transparency, universality, and individual responsibility in ways that often occlude racial difference. Other artists, however, disrupt crisis vision by confronting white supremacy and destabilizing hierarchies through the performance of opacity. Whether fostering a recognition of a shared responsibility and complicity for the violence of crisis vision or critiquing how vulnerable groups are constructed and treated globally, these artists emphasize ethical relations between strangers and ask viewers to question their own place within unjust social orders. 

    Hart-Davidson, W., & Ridolfo, J. (2019). Rhet Ops: Rhetoric and Information Warfare. Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press. 

    In this edited volume, authors seek to document and analyze how state and non-state actors leverage digital rhetoric as a twenty-first-century weapon of war. Rhet Ops offer readers a chance to focus on the human dimension of rhetorical practice within mobile technologies and social networks: to reflect not only on the durable question of what it means to conduct oneself ethically as a speaker or writer, but also what it means to learn the art of rhetoric as a means to engage adversaries in war and conflict. 

    Saltes, N. (2013). ‘Abnormal’ bodies on the borders of inclusion: Biopolitics and the paradox of disability surveillance. Surveillance & Society, 11(1/2), 55-73. https://doi.org/10.24908/ss.v11i1/2.4460 

    When conducted according to the biomedical definition of disability, ‘disability surveillance’ involves monitoring bodies against normative ontological standards, classifying ‘abnormality’ and problematizing ‘abnormal bodies’ as risky. While disability surveillance that operates within a biomedical perspective contributes to the exclusion of disabled people, the counting and classifying of disabled people is necessary to achieve the aims and objectives of the disability rights movement. In examining this paradox, this paper looks at the ways in which the Canadian government defines and measures disability and the implication of discriminatory immigration policies and ableist biometric technologies. A theoretical framework with which to situate and examine disability surveillance is proposed. Drawing from the work of Foucault on normality/abnormality and subsequent literature on biopolitics, this paper contextualizes the paradoxical implications of surveillance practices that target disabled people. 

    Stagliano, A. (2024). Disobedient aesthetics: Surveillance, bodies, control. University of Alabama Press. 

    The contemporary world bristles with tools of observation and manipulation. Security cameras, social media, data mining, biometric scans, and other instruments ensnare the individual in a web of surveillance. In Disobedient Aesthetics, Anthony Stagliano exposes the use of human lives as sites of data exploitation and outlines paths of resistance. From the thermal-vision systems used on military drones, which use human body heat itself as a media object, to facial recognition platforms that use human faces as data mines, and from law enforcement tools of DNA analysis to data-driven urban governance, the realm of algorithmic surveillance and control is wide and subtle. Disobedient Aesthetics outlines interventions into the technical systems subtending data-driven surveillance and control. Stagliano maps not only the surveillant regimes afforded by recent networked technologies, but also the inventive, artistic research into ways of undermining, upending, or redirecting such technologies. The concluding chapter examines creative, critical, and collective efforts to democratize access to the technology that undergirds such scrutiny and enables ways to detect and contest its power. In a fascinating epilogue, Stagliano revisits current theories of control and offers an alternative reading of Gilles Deleuze’s oft-cited thesis on control societies: namely that it is not a matter of “finding new weapons” to undermine control but developing new techniques, new designs, new prototypes, and new modes of creative escape. 

    Vetter, M. A., & McDowell, Z. J. (2023). A spectrum of surveillance: Charting functions of epistemic inequality across EdTech platforms in the post-COVID-19 era across EdTech platforms in the post-COVID-19 era. Journal of University Teaching & Learning Practice, 20(2). https://doi.org/10.53761/1.20.02.02 

    Covid-19 and the public health policies emerging in response have laid bare a multiplicity of issues related to educational access and knowledge equity on a global scale. Among these, the quick shift to online and hybrid education models led teachers to adapt a plethora of digital platforms to deliver content and sponsor interactions). Such platforms range from institutionally sanctioned (and subscribed) Learning Management Systems (LMSs) to software provided by organizations beyond the institution and can pose a threat to student data and privacy. Data surveillance in educational contexts is not a new issue, nor is it only a strictly digital problem. However, the current milieu of constant and continuing public health crises has led to more frequent, uncritical, and hurried adoption of learning technologies. This article challenges professionals in higher education specifically to take a more critical look at the various EdTech platforms they are, have, and will adopt in the post-COVID-19 era, and the spectrum of surveillance such platforms enact. Through a review of common entities such as LMSs, Google Workspace for Education, and Zoom video conferencing software, this article demonstrates how these technologies place both teachers and students in a relationship to data and learning characterised by “epistemic inequality” or “unequal access to learning imposed by private commercial mechanisms''. By taking a closer look at the problematic surveillance functioning across EdTech, this article makes a case for Commons-based Peer Production communities as equitable, open educational alternatives that have resisted market-based neoliberalism and surveillance capitalism. 

  • Copyright, Intellectual Property, and User Data

    Bender, E.M., Gebru, T., McMillan-Major, A., & Shmitchell, S. (2021). On the dangers of stochastic parrots: Can language models be too big? Proceedings of the 2021 ACM Conference on Fairness, Accountability, and Transparency, FAccT ‘21 (pp. 610–623). Association for Computing Machinery, New York, NY, USA. 

    The past 3 years of work in NLP have been characterized by the development and deployment of ever larger language models, especially for English. BERT, its variants, GPT-2/3, and others, most recently Switch-C, have pushed the boundaries of the possible both through architectural innovations and through sheer size. Using these pretrained models and the methodology of fine-tuning them for specific tasks, researchers have extended the state of the art on a wide array of tasks as measured by leaderboards on specific benchmarks for English. In this paper, we take a step back and ask: How big is too big? What are the possible risks associated with this technology and what paths are available for mitigating those risks? We provide recommendations including weighing the environmental and financial costs first, investing resources into curating and carefully documenting datasets rather than ingesting everything on the web, carrying out pre-development exercises evaluating how the planned approach fits into research and development goals and supports stakeholder values, and encouraging research directions beyond ever larger language models. 

    Citron, D.K., & Solove, D. (2022). Privacy Harms. Boston University Law Review, 102(793). 

    The requirement of harm has significantly impeded the enforcement of privacy law. In most tort and contract cases, plaintiffs must establish that they have suffered harm. Even when legislation does not require it, courts have taken it upon themselves to add a harm element. Harm is also a requirement to establish standing in federal court. In Spokeo, Inc. v. Robins and TransUnion LLC v. Ramirez, the Supreme Court ruled that courts can override congressional judgment about cognizable harm and dismiss privacy claims.  Case law is an inconsistent, incoherent jumble with no guiding principles. Countless privacy violations are not remedied or addressed on the grounds that there has been no cognizable harm. Courts struggle with privacy harms because they often involve future uses of personal data that vary widely. When privacy violations result in negative consequences, the effects are often small—frustration, aggravation, anxiety, inconvenience—and dispersed among a large number of people. When these minor harms are suffered at a vast scale, they produce significant harm to individuals, groups, and society. But these harms do not fit well with existing cramped judicial understandings of harm. This Article makes two central contributions. The first is the construction of a typology for courts to understand harm so that privacy violations can be tackled and remedied in a meaningful way. Privacy harms consist of various different types that have been recognized by courts in inconsistent ways. Our typology of privacy harms elucidates why certain types of privacy harms should be recognized as cognizable.  This Article’s second contribution is providing an approach to when privacy harm should be required. In many cases, harm should not be required because it is irrelevant to the purpose of the lawsuit. Currently, much privacy litigation suffers from a misalignment of enforcement goals and remedies. We contend that the law should be guided by the essential question: When and how should privacy regulation be enforced? We offer an approach that aligns enforcement goals with appropriate remedies. 

    Kerr, I., Lucock, C., & Steeves, V. (2009). Lessons from the identity trail: Anonymity, privacy, and identity in a networked society. Oxford: Oxford University Press. 

    Privacy and issues of identity are examined through an interdisciplinary lens, informed by the results of a major research project that brought together a distinguished array of philosophers, ethicists, cognitive scientists, lawyers, cryptographers, engineers, policy analysts, government policy makers and privacy experts. The text examines key questions about anonymity, privacy, and identity in an environment that increasingly automates the collection of personal information and uses surveillance to reduce corporate and security risks. 

     Reyman, J. (2013). User data on the social web: Authorship, agency, and appropriation. College English, 75(5), 513-533. https://doi.org/10.58680/ce201323565 

    Social web services catalog users’ activities across the Internet, aggregating, analyzing, and selling a vast array of user data to be used largely for consumer profiling and target marketing. This article interrogates the tacit agreements and terms-of-use policies that govern who owns user data, how it circulates, and how it can be used. Relying on problematic assumptions about the authorship of social data, data-mining practices and technology policies unquestioningly place ownership in the hands of technology companies and compel users to surrender control over their own contributions on the social web. This article explores the implications of the practices and policies surrounding data management for composition and participation on the social web and argues for a more balanced distribution of rights to user data. 

    Zuboff, S. (2019). The age of surveillance capitalism: The fight for a human future at the new frontier of power. Profile Books.  

    Harvard Business School describes Shoshana Zuboff’s book as providing startling insights into the phenomenon that she has named surveillance capitalism. The stakes could not be higher: a global architecture of behavior modification threatens human nature in the 21st century just as industrial capitalism disfigured the natural world in the 20th century. Zuboff vividly brings to life the consequences as surveillance capitalism advances from Silicon Valley into every economic sector. Vast wealth and power are accumulated in ominous new “behavioral futures markets,” where predictions about our behavior are bought and sold, and the production of goods and services is subordinated to a new “means of behavioral modification.” The threat has shifted from a totalitarian Big Brother state to a ubiquitous digital architecture: a “Big Other” operating in the interests of surveillance capital. Here is the crucible of an unprecedented form of power marked by extreme concentrations of knowledge and free from democratic oversight. Zuboff’s comprehensive and moving analysis lays bare the threats to 21st century society: a controlled “hive” of total connection that seduces with promises of total certainty for maximum profit—at the expense of democracy, freedom, and our human future. With little resistance from law or society, surveillance capitalism is on the verge of dominating the social order and shaping the digital future—if we let it. 

  • Transnational Surveillance

    Chen, C. (2024). Digital surveillance and control of Chinese feminists and a transnational response. In M. C. Banville and G. P. Johnson (Eds)., Talking back through rhetorical surveillance studies: Intersectional feminist and queer approaches [Cluster Conversation]. Peitho, 27(1). https://doi.org/10.37514/PEI-J.2024.27.1.06 

    Using a case study of violence against Chinese feminists, this article illustrates how contemporary and historic surveillance technologies (digital and pre-digital) specifically impact transnational, non-western communities and how transnational studies support or complicate feminist insights on the rhetorical contours of surveillance. Applying the concept of deep circulation (Edwards), I chart the contemporary strategies of surveilling Chinese feminists through textual, affective, and infrastructural dimensions. These surveillance strategies use the rhetorics of “Da Zi Bao” (Big Character Posters) from China’s Cultural Revolution era to label feminists as traitors to the nation, which thrive in a nationalist affective economy supported by political and technological infrastructures that use technological instrumental power to control information circulation. The article ends with a brief discussion of Chinese feminists’ transnational response, disengaging from the discourse based on nationalism, and a call for action for Western audiences to examine the global impacts of Western technologies. 

    Webb, M. (2006). Illusions of security: Global surveillance and democracy in the post‑9/11 world. City Lights Publishers. 

    In light of terrorist threats at U.K and U.S. airports, this book is a timely and provocative read about what governments should and should not be doing to protect us from further terrorist attacks. It is a crucial look at a little-examined aspect of the U.S.-led “war on terror”–the move toward the use of mass, globalized surveillance and a “preemptive” model of security, and its effects on democratic values and human rights around the world. 

Grassroots Organizations 

We would be remiss if we did not mention several of the organizations who have been challenging surveillance practices, and fighting for basic human rights such as privacy protections. While this list is by no means an exhaustive or extensive list, we hope that it serves as a starting point for those who are interested in some of the activism work happening across the globe.

S.T.O.P. fights to end discriminatory surveillance. Their team challenges both individual misconduct and broader systemic failures, crafting policies that balance new technologies and age-old rights. They also educate impacted communities on how they can protect their rights. 

A group of artists, engineers, activists, and technologists who have been behind the largest online protests in human history, channeling Internet outrage into political power to win public interest victories previously thought to be impossible. They fight for a future where technology is a force for liberation— not oppression.  

The group aims to combat structural racism and unjustified surveillance of minorities and activist movements by bringing together leaders of intersecting social justice movements, facilitating the sharing of tactics and information about ongoing campaigns, and supporting emerging intersectional efforts to protect the safety and dignity of our communities. A collaboration of American Friends Service Committee, Boston Workmans Circle, Defending Rights & Dissent, Intelligent Mischief, and the Muslim Justice League. 

The Electronic Frontier Foundation is the leading nonprofit organization defending civil liberties in the digital world. Founded in 1990, EFF champions user privacy, free expression, and innovation through impact litigation, policy analysis, grassroots activism, and technology development. EFF's mission is to ensure that technology supports freedom, justice, and innovation for all people of the world. 

  • Electronic Privacy Information Center Epic.org  

EPIC’s mission is to secure the fundamental right to privacy in the digital age for all people through advocacy, research, and litigation. They are a 501(c)(3) non-profit research and advocacy center.  

Additional Media and Resources